If you’re preparing to sell your home in McHenry, IL, one of the simplest and most cost-effective upgrades you can make is a fresh coat of paint. But not just any color will do. The right paint colors can enhance your home’s appeal, make it feel more spacious, and even increase your resale value.
As trusted house painters in McHenry, Allegiant Painting shares our top recommendations for house painting colors that not only look great—but also help homes sell faster and for more.
Why Paint Color Matters When Selling Your Home
Buyers form first impressions fast—within seconds of walking through the door. Neutral, modern colors help them envision their life in the space, while bold or outdated hues can be a turn-off.
According to real estate professionals and painting experts alike, the right paint job can offer a 200% return on investment or more. That’s why choosing smart, strategic colors is a crucial part of prepping your home for the market.
Best Interior Paint Colors for Resale Value
1. Warm Neutrals (Beige, Greige, Soft Taupe)
Top Picks: Sherwin-Williams “Accessible Beige,” Benjamin Moore “Edgecomb Gray”
These inviting, versatile shades appeal to the widest range of buyers. They create a cozy and clean feel without overpowering the space.
Perfect for: Living rooms, bedrooms, hallways
Why it works: Warm tones feel welcoming and help buyers focus on the home—not the paint
2. Soft Whites
Top Picks: Benjamin Moore “Chantilly Lace,” Sherwin-Williams “Alabaster”
Soft whites make spaces feel open, clean, and timeless. Ideal for smaller homes in McHenry, where maximizing light and space is key.
Perfect for: Kitchens, ceilings, trim, small rooms
Why it works: Light colors make homes feel larger and brighter
3. Cool Grays and Greiges
Top Picks: Sherwin-Williams “Repose Gray,” Benjamin Moore “Classic Gray”
Grays with a slight warmth or beige undertone (a.k.a. greige) offer a modern and sophisticated feel without being too cold or sterile.
Perfect for: Dining rooms, bathrooms, offices
Why it works: Neutral but modern—perfect balance of trend and tradition
4. Muted Blues and Soft Greens
Top Picks: Behr “Light French Gray,” Benjamin Moore “Pale Oak”
While bold colors may alienate buyers, subtle versions of blue and green can evoke calm, clean energy.
Perfect for: Bathrooms, bedrooms, accent walls
Why it works: Evokes a spa-like atmosphere without overwhelming the space
Best Exterior Paint Colors for Curb Appeal and Value
The outside of your home is just as important as the inside—especially when buyers are browsing online listings or doing a drive-by.
1. Classic White with Black Accents
Why it works: Crisp, clean, and timeless. A black door or shutters adds contrast and sophistication.
2. Warm Grays or Light Taupe
Why it works: These neutral colors blend well with the natural tones found in McHenry’s landscapes and seasons.
3. Navy or Charcoal Accents
Why it works: Adds depth and character to doors, shutters, or trim without taking over the palette.
💡 Pro Tip: Pair your exterior colors with the style of your home and the surrounding neighborhood for maximum resale impact.
House Painting FAQs
What color house has the highest resale value?
Neutral colors like beige, greige, and soft white have the broadest appeal and consistently lead to higher resale values.
Should I repaint before selling my house?
Yes. A fresh coat of paint is one of the most affordable and effective ways to boost curb appeal and market value.
What is the most popular color for interior house painting in 2025?
Soft greiges and warm whites remain at the top of color trend lists for 2025, offering versatility and buyer appeal.
How Allegiant Painting Helps You Choose the Right Colors
At Allegiant Painting, we don’t just offer top-quality house painting in McHenry, IL—we offer local insight and professional color consultation. We understand the nuances of the McHenry real estate market and know which colors work best for resale in our area.
Our experienced house painters:
- Use premium, low-VOC paints for healthier indoor air
- Help match colors to your home’s style and lighting
- Ensure smooth, flawless finishes that impress buyers
Final Thoughts: Boosting Value with Paint
If you’re selling your home in McHenry, a professional house painting project can dramatically improve both its look and value. By selecting the right interior and exterior colors, you’re not just refreshing your space—you’re creating a more marketable, desirable home for potential buyers.
Schedule Your Free Estimate Today
📍 Allegiant Painting | McHenry, IL
🎨 Interior & Exterior House Painting Experts
